Item data
Item Type:
Document
From:
Knapp, John Leonard
Sent from:
Bath, Somerset
To:
Smith, Sir James Edward
Sent to location:
Norwich, Norfolk
Summary:
Reassures Smith that [William] Sole did not leave anything abusive towards Smith in his manuscripts [Sole took umbrage at Smith's classification of 'Mentha' in "Flora Britannica"]. Explains that Sole did not know Linnaeus' system and believed that the authority of Jean Johannes Bauhin [(1541-1613)], Caspar Bauhin [(1560-1624)], Sir John Hill [(1714-1775)], [John] Ray and others were sufficient to establish the species and Smith should consider these notes "harmless remarks of a mind cowed by disappointment". Sole's notes now in possession of a friend of Smith's, and one unknown clergyman has already been denied permission to publish them. As Smith plans to dedicate a genus to Sole relinquishes his own intentions for same, if 'Agrostis minima' is to be used suggests substituting 'minima' for another word, hopes [James] Sowerby has delinated it in the same way. Requests ['Agrostis littoralis']. Found a ['Bromus arvensis'] that corresponds exactly with the specimen in [William] Sherard's [(1659-1728)] herbarium and with [Johann Georg Daniel] Leers' [(1727-1774)] and "Scheuatzer's" descriptions, subsequently his representation will differ from that in "English Botany".
Letter date:
28 Nov [1802]
Languages:
English
Prev Ref No:
6.14
Additional Information:
Note type | Note |
---|
Related Material | For Knapp's attempts to obtain the volume containing Sole's notes see JES/COR/6/12. For further on renaming 'Agrostis minima' see JES/COR/6/8; JES/COR/6/10.
Smith, J E, (1800-1804). "Flora Britannica" London: Davis.
Smith, J E, Sowerby, J, (1790-1814). "English Botany" London. |
Finding Aids | Dawson, W R, (1934). "Catalogue of the manuscripts in the Library of The Linnean Society - Part I. The Smith papers: The correspondence and miscellaneous papers of Sir James Edward Smith", London: Linnean Society. |
Additional | Smith replied 30 Dec [1802] |